With one daughter in her freshman year and two more headed into theirs, I'm quite done with sorting through all of the college literature, remembering deadline dates, and coughing up personal financial data. Still, I must say, the thrill of seeing the kids get their acceptances never dies.
Lately, that's gotten tricky here, what with twins who have applied mostly to the same schools. Examining their college apps, admissions counselors would have to search for the nuances. Their GPAs are within a couple of tenths of each other, and their ACT scores a point apart. Their extracurricular activities pretty much match up one to one, and they share the same work history. And as a mom, not to mention a professional editor, I'd say each did a bang-up job on her essays, too. (And, no, I did not write them -- nor did we hire out for that, as many do these days.)
Here's the thing. One daughter is currently sitting on three acceptances, and has been for weeks now. The other has received one. She's not been turned down by the others but hasn't heard the "Yes, we'd love to have you here" from them, either -- the early acceptance notice periods haven't expired in either case. So what gives?
I could get all crazy and turn this into a numbers game. The one who has the acceptances has the lower ACT score and the slightly higher GPA, but with fewer honors classes. Does GPA factor in higher than ACT score? In one case, she submitted the application one day ahead of her sister. Does a day make a difference -- in weeks -- of getting an application processed? Or, did that higher ACT score bump my second daughter into a different acceptance category, one for which the schools are sorting out special scholarship potential?
That last one gets to the real heart of the matter for me. I'm fairly confident that where one gets accepted, the other one will, too. They are, after all, as identical on paper as they are in physical appearance. But what does this mean for us financially? One school has offered Daughter No. 1 a pleasantly surprising four-year merit scholarship, and another has put her into a priority queue for financial aid and merit awards, the deadline for which is today. So that doesn't look so great for Daughter No. 2 -- unless, as I imagine in my most wistful state -- it has really set her aside for something extra special.
It's difficult not to think about the data points I know about my daughters and to try gleaning insight from them. Then I put that in greater context and, well, my mind goes numb. Did Daughter No. 2's application get lost in the big-data sinkhole, never to surface again?
Colleges and universities, like their counterparts in the business and government worlds, do face a data glut. And while higher education as an industry is learning how to make better use of all the student data it has, it's not fully versed yet. I love this analogy from Brian Parish, president of IData, a higher ed technology consulting and software solutions firm. "It's interesting watching schools that have struggled with what you might call 'small data' for a long time now being told big-data is the answer. It can feel like giving a racecar to someone who has been riding a bicycle," he told me in a phone interview yesterday.
But enrollment is one area where schools are starting to see big-data help make a difference, he said. With more data, schools are able to better target potential students and cull through applicants. I'm not sure where the schools on my daughters' hit lists fall in their use of big-data here, but I do hope it turns out to their advantage. We'll know soon enough -- well, sort of!
And in the meantime, I'll be picking Parish's brains some more on how higher ed is using big-data today and the future outlook (did I mention I have an 11-year-old, too?). Parish will be joining AllAnalytics.com next week for an e-chat on big-data in higher ed. Join us on Friday, December 14, at 2:00 p.m. ET as we talk about how big-data is coming into play in processes such as enrollment, course planning, and retention -- and the challenges therein. The e-chat will take place here.