Bryan Beverly

A Skeptic's Guide to Analytic Results

NO RATINGS
View Comments: Newest First | Oldest First | Threaded View
Page 1 / 3   >   >>
Broadway
User Rank
Blogger
Re: Respectfully pushing back
Broadway   2/12/2014 8:07:24 PM
NO RATINGS
I would add a couple additional "leadership" animals --- the snake, the passive-aggressive types who will destroy you when you turn your back on them, and the vultures, who wait out all the foxes and lions and pick their carcasses after the fight. 

bkbeverly
User Rank
Data Doctor
Re: Respectfully pushing back
bkbeverly   2/12/2014 5:04:09 PM
NO RATINGS
@Broadway, I greatly admire your optimism; I used to think just like that when I younger. It's wonderful to be a middle-aged person, but the downside is that time has a way of making one a skeptic. I agree that over time, work places will be less combat-oriented. I think that the gradual increase in women in the white-collar labor force is slowly forcing work place culture to be less Spartan-like (or at least the lawyers are doing that). But your hopes for a better day remind me of Vilfredo Pareto's theory of the circulation of elites. He said that leadership styles cycle through periods of lions (traditional male brute force and intimidation) and foxes (people who can covertly manipulate, massage and convince people to do their bidding). I can see a day when cultures are kinder and gentler. But I would warn you that whether you work with lions or foxes, the outcome for the slow and weak will be the same. Foxes are just as predatory as lions, they just are kinder and gentler in their approach. But ultimately, the goal is to 'do you in'; a soft approach but just as deadly. So keep your whether combative or diplomatic, keep your skepticism radar up - trust but verify!

Broadway
User Rank
Blogger
Re: Respectfully pushing back
Broadway   2/11/2014 10:55:47 PM
NO RATINGS
@bkbeverly, you are right. Some "old dogs" still like to fight like young pups. And there are still plenty of dogs that will wait till your not looking and will nip at your heels. One day all company cultures will be kinder and gentler but until then ...

bkbeverly
User Rank
Data Doctor
Re: And then there is bias
bkbeverly   2/11/2014 10:14:15 AM
NO RATINGS
Meta, Could not agree with you more. Bias is a chronic problem in sampling. As in the case you mentioned, it was a random sample of people with at least a BA/BS degree. Bias is also a problem in survey design and reporting. People with advanced degrees tend to write to the level of their peers. Some of these survey results represent a 'privileged class' and not the thoughts of Joe or Jane Lunchbucket. Nothing wrong with that as long as you state that the external validity applies to white collar professionals. When your colleagues, neighbors and Facebook friends are in the same socioeconomic status groups, then one's perception of applicable analytical truths is skewed. Not intentional, not malicious, but innate and habitual. When the only people in your circle of associations are like you, then the assumptions or assertions you make should be 'viewed with a jaundiced eye'. Good observation (as always).

bkbeverly
User Rank
Data Doctor
Re: Respectfully pushing back
bkbeverly   2/10/2014 4:36:59 PM
NO RATINGS
@Broadway - Not a specific event. Just a gradual realization that it was a hollow victory to attack a person and not constructively work toward refining ideas. Particularly since many environments are charged with testosterone, challenging a coworker or a superior that you wanted to knock off was expected. When you were a young pup, you wanted to prove that you were ready to be a big dog. But when you are a young pup, you do not know that every big dog one day becomes an old dog. No not a specific incident in this case - just a gradual maturing. Every one grows old, but some never grow up; there are some gray haired babies whose insecurities find it better to reaffirm themselves by attacking others rather than preserving the dignity of others and helping them to shape their ideas. It is nothing wrong with being a skeptic, but it can turn out wrong if it is done the wrong way for the wrong reason. So all that to say is that these are the lessons learned from an old dog. I can't learn any new tricks, but I know when someone is trying to play them.

BethSchultz
User Rank
Blogger
Re: healthy skepticism
BethSchultz   2/10/2014 9:18:00 AM
NO RATINGS
From your blog post to a real-world example of healthy skepticism. Perfect!

Meta S. Brown
User Rank
Blogger
And then there is bias
Meta S. Brown   2/10/2014 9:12:14 AM
NO RATINGS
Bryan,

I love this post - these are terrific points, and all should be taken into account!

May I also add that we should examine methods for signs of plain old ordinary bias? For example, I've seen a number of posts recently about a data science salary survey. Most of the posts push the value of certain skills, based on the survey results.

A quick review of the survey report reveals that all the respondents were attendees of one particular conference. That conference focuses on certain specific skills, and certain types of applications. It's by no means a representative sample of the analytics community, or even the "data science" community as a whole. It's a biased sample, and it's obvious that nobody even tried to eliminate bias when planning the survey.

Alas, that's a common problem.

Broadway
User Rank
Blogger
Re: Respectfully pushing back
Broadway   2/9/2014 11:39:09 PM
NO RATINGS
@bkbeverly, was there a specific event that flicked on the light bulb?

bkbeverly
User Rank
Data Doctor
Re: Respectfully pushing back
bkbeverly   2/8/2014 7:48:17 PM
NO RATINGS
Broadway, I used to be one of those persons! In an academic environment, that is the way of life. It feeds the ego when you think you have won a round of one-upsmanship. But over the years, I learned that it is better to make colleagues than enemies. In fact, "there are no permanent friends and there are no permanent enemies, but there are permanent interests". The person you intellectually attack today may be a needed friend tomorrow. And since all of us have strengths and weaknesses, you really gain nothing by seeking to show up someone because what goes around comes around. So over the years, I found it more constructive to question the range of options rather than attack a person. Oh I am quite tempted sometimes when someone else makes a first strike at me; the natural response is to hit back. And even then I have to quickly assess if the statement is personal or professional. Cannot say that I always respond like a grown up. But I do try not to initiate conflict. So yes, I try these days to take a softer approach, but oh no, that is not how I started out.

Broadway
User Rank
Blogger
Re: Respectfully pushing back
Broadway   2/8/2014 6:22:15 PM
NO RATINGS
@bkbeverly, granted I was in grad school nearly 15 years ago and it was for a liberal arts degree, but back then students and teachers didn't question -- they always accused and attacked. Why is this relevant? Etc. etc. perhaps it was the culture of that school.

Page 1 / 3   >   >>
Information Resources
More Blogs from Bryan Beverly
Consider this: Is knowledge in your organization created by technology or by the people associated with the organization? Bryan Beverly kicks off the discussion.
Bryan Beverly asks how we should view big data, and whether it is an ultimate truth. He proposes a three-question test to see how big data fits into your organization.
Analytics pros need to understand their company dynamics when it comes to compensation and survival. Yes, there are ways to avoid being the slowest gazelle in the herd.
Quantum physics and quantum computing could turn many of the core principles of analytics on their heads. Big becomes small. True becomes maybe. Predictability becomes unpredictability.
It's time for a fresh look at how crime statistics are reported and viewed, and analytics professionals are in a position to raise appropriate questions.
Radio Show
A2 Conversations
UPCOMING
James M. Connolly
How Predictive Analytics Can Take Your Company to the Next Level


6/28/2016   REGISTER   0
UPCOMING
James M. Connolly
Analytics: Where We've Been, Where We're Going


7/12/2016   REGISTER   0
ARCHIVE
James M. Connolly
How Analytics Can Transform State Government


5/17/2016  LISTEN   51
ARCHIVE
James M. Connolly
Save Labor Costs With Predictive Analytics


5/10/2016  LISTEN   53
ARCHIVE
James M. Connolly
What the IoT Means to You and Your Insurer


5/6/2016  LISTEN   75
ARCHIVE
James M. Connolly
When It's Time for a Robot's Job Review


4/27/2016  LISTEN   21
ARCHIVE
James M. Connolly
How Advanced Analytics Serve Healthcare


4/12/2016  LISTEN   88
ARCHIVE
James M. Connolly
Life in a World of Big Data, Autonomous Cars and IoT


3/17/2016  LISTEN   34
ARCHIVE
James M. Connolly
Sports Analytics: Driving the Business Forward


3/10/2016  LISTEN   73
ARCHIVE
James M. Connolly
See How Data is Revolutionizing Healthcare


2/25/2016  LISTEN   78
ARCHIVE
James M. Connolly
Why Analytics are So Valuable in Cybersecurity


2/18/2016  LISTEN   47
ARCHIVE
James M. Connolly
The Analytics Job and Salary Outlook for 2016


1/28/2016  LISTEN   16
Information Resources
Quick Poll
Quick Poll
About Us  |  Contact Us  |  Help  |  Register  |  Twitter  |  Facebook  |  RSS